J-VALVES · Ball Valve Manufacturer · Wenzhou, China info@j-valves.com +86-13600648865

API 6D ball valve selection guide

News

Home News Remanufactured Ball Valves: Five Checks That Decide Whether A Rebuild Deserves A Certificate
Inquire
Refurbished trunnion ball valve stripped to the body in a repair workshop with ball and seat ring on a bench

Forty valves went out to a rebuild shop and forty came back, each with a certificate reading that the valve had been remanufactured to original specification, hydrostatically tested and sealed. Eleven of them should have been scrapped. One had a body wall of 8.9 millimetres where the applicable table minimum was 12.7. It had passed its shell test without a weep, which is exactly the point: a hydrostatic test proves that the body does not burst today. It says nothing about whether it will burst in year nine, and a wall that has lost a third of its thickness to erosion is a wall whose remaining life is a corrosion calculation rather than a test result.

Remanufacture is a legitimate and often excellent answer to an ageing valve population. In a refinery with eight thousand valves and a maintenance budget that will not fund replacement at list price, a properly executed rebuild programme is the difference between a plant that runs and one that does not. But the word covers everything from a genuine remanufacture with a new ball, a new seat, new trim and a re-certified body, down to a wash, a repaint and a new set of seals. Both arrive with a certificate. Only one of them is worth the freight.

The five checks below are the ones that separate the two, and they are all things a buyer can require in the purchase order and verify on receipt.

1. Four routes, and four different pieces of paper

The first decision is not whether to rebuild, but which of four routes the valve is actually being sent down. They differ in what is replaced, what can be certified, and what the valve is worth afterwards.

Route

What is replaced

Certificate that is honestly available

Typical price vs new

Repair

Seals and gaskets only, body and trim untouched

Works test report, no material certification

8 to 15 percent

Refurbish

Seals, gaskets, seat rings, ball re-polished in place

Works test report plus dimensional record

25 to 40 percent

Remanufacture

New ball, new seats, new stem and bearings, body re-machined and re-tested

3.1 achievable only if the body heat number survives and no welding is done

40 to 60 percent

Replace in kind

Everything, with a new body

Full 3.1, impact values, fire certificate, NACE

100 percent

The failure mode of the market is a valve bought on the refurbish price and delivered with a remanufacture certificate. That is not a commercial quibble: the certificate is what the integrity management system relies on when it decides the valve is fit for a hydrocarbon line, and a certificate that overstates what was done is worse than no certificate at all, because it removes the incentive to look.

2. Check one: wall thickness against the table minimum, not against the drawing

The most common error in a rebuild specification is to accept a body at ninety percent of nominal on the grounds that the mill tolerance allows twelve and a half percent. That tolerance belongs to pipe and plate. A valve body is measured against the minimum wall table in ASME B16.34, and the values in that table are already minimums, not nominal dimensions. There is no tolerance to spend.

The numbers are small enough to memorise. For a DN100 body, the table minimum is about 9.5 millimetres in Class 150, 12.7 in Class 300 and 17.5 in Class 600. A DN100 Class 300 body that arrives at 8.9 has not lost a tolerance, it has lost 30 percent of its pressure boundary, and the question is not whether it passes a test but where the metal went. In slurry and ash service the answer is usually the same place every time: the upstream seat pocket and the bore immediately downstream of the seat, where the jet attaches at part open.

Ultrasonic measurement on a grid is the only way to find that. A hundred millimetre grid on the body, the bonnet and both end connections, with a minimum of twelve readings on a DN100 and forty on a DN600, and the readings reported as a map rather than a single minimum. A rebuild shop that reports one number has measured the easiest place to reach, which is never the place that failed.

3. Check two: the two certificates that cannot be rebuilt

This is where most of the real risk sits, and it is almost never discussed at the quotation stage.

An EN 10204 3.1 certificate is a statement that the material in the valve can be traced to a specific heat and that the mechanical properties of that heat were tested. Without a legible heat number on the body, that statement cannot be made, and no amount of testing on the finished valve will restore it. What can be issued is a 2.2, which is a statement that the supplier has carried out tests and considers the result to conform, without third party traceability. A 2.2 is a perfectly good document. It is not the same document, and a specification that requires 3.1 is not satisfied by it.

NACE MR0175 is recoverable, but only partly. Hardness can be measured on the finished body with a portable instrument, but the uncertainty of a Leeb or UCI reading is of the order of two to three points on the Rockwell C scale. Against a twenty-two HRC limit, a reading of twenty is not proof of compliance; it is a reading that is consistent with compliance. Alloy identity can be confirmed by positive material identification, but PMI confirms chemistry and says nothing about heat treatment. So a rebuilt valve for sour service is certifiable when the original 3.1 survives, the chemistry is confirmed on the body, the hardness has margin, and no welding has been done anywhere on the pressure boundary.

Low temperature service is where the route closes completely. Charpy impact values come from destroying test pieces cut from the heat, and a used body has no test pieces to cut. Subsize specimens can be taken in principle, but the correlation between subsize and full size absorbed energy is a standardised adjustment that the original certificate does not contain, so the result is an opinion rather than a qualification. A rebuilt valve offered for minus 46 degrees without its original impact data is a valve with a claim and no evidence, and no amount of hydrostatic testing changes that, because brittle fracture is not a pressure phenomenon at test temperature.

4. Check three: the ball is a ground part, and grinding has a budget

The ball looks like the easy item to recondition, and it is the one that most often comes back wrong. A new ball is round to between one and three hundredths of a millimetre and carries a hard coating: hard chrome at 50 to 100 micrometres, or a tungsten carbide HVOF layer at 150 to 300. In service the coating wears at the sealing band, and the ball goes out of round by a tenth of a millimetre or so, which is ten times its original tolerance.

Re-grinding restores the roundness and removes coating. Each pass takes 0.05 to 0.10 millimetres off the diameter, so a ball with a 75 micrometre chrome layer has no coating left after the first pass, and what comes back is a polished stainless sphere with the hardness of stainless. That is acceptable in clean dry service and unacceptable in anything abrasive. A ball that has been ground twice must be quoted with a new seat pair, and the seat must be matched to the finished ball diameter, because the whole sealing mechanism depends on the seat being compressed by a defined amount.

That compression is the number to hold on to. A soft seat is compressed by 0.3 to 0.5 millimetres when the valve is assembled. Grinding 0.2 millimetres off the ball diameter consumes 40 to 65 percent of that compression before the valve has seen any service, which means the seat has no reserve for thermal movement, for pressure cycling, or for the next rebuild. A rebuilt valve whose ball has been ground and whose seat was reused is a valve with half its sealing margin already spent, and it will pass the leak test at the shop because the shop test is at ambient with a static differential.

5. Check four: which valves can be repaired at all

Not every body can be re-machined, and the difference is structural rather than commercial. In a side entry valve the body seat face sits inside the bore, behind a seat pocket that is only accessible through the end connection. Re-facing that surface in place requires a boring bar long enough to reach it and rigid enough not to chatter, and most workshops cannot do it, so what happens instead is lapping by hand, which removes the geometry that the seat ring locates on. In a top entry valve the whole internals assembly lifts out through the bonnet, the body seat faces are presented to the tool, and the operation is routine.

That is the practical reason a top entry valve commands a premium and the reason a rebuild programme should start by sorting the population by construction rather than by size. Welded body valves are a third category again: a fully welded ball valve can be cut open and re-welded, and once it has been, the pressure boundary has a weld in it that was not there when the valve was certified, which brings the whole qualification question back to the surface.

6. Check five: the test that is never in the rebuild scope

Every rebuild includes a shell test at 1.5 times the cold rating and a seat test at 1.1 times. Those are necessary and they are not sufficient, because they are both performed once, at ambient, on an assembly that has just been built. The failures that bring rebuilt valves back are not failures of the lapping; they are failures of the assembly, and they appear on the second operation, not the first.

Three additions close the gap, and all three fit in a normal workshop day. A cycle test, a hundred open and close strokes at rated pressure with torque logged every ten, which beds the seats and exposes an assembly error before the valve ships. A thermal cycle, three cycles up to design temperature and back, with the seat tested hot once the third cycle is complete, for anything above 200 degrees. And a repeat seat test after the cycle test, because a seat that seals on a fresh lap and leaks after a hundred strokes was assembled with the wrong compression, and the only place that is visible is the second test.

Ask for the torque log with the certificate. A shop that has run the cycles has the data; a shop that has not will offer a paragraph explaining why the test is not applicable to this size, and that paragraph is the answer to the question.

Check

What is measured

Acceptance

What it catches

Body wall

Ultrasonic grid on body, bonnet and both ends, 100 mm pitch

No reading below the B16.34 table minimum, reported as a map

Lost pressure boundary, usually at the upstream seat pocket

Traceability

Heat number on the body, PMI, portable hardness

Certificate type agreed in advance; hardness with margin against 22 HRC

A 2.2 sold as a 3.1, and sour service claimed without evidence

Ball

Roundness, coating thickness after grinding, matched seats

Coating intact, roundness restored, new seat pair if the ball was ground

Half the seat compression spent before the valve enters service

Repairability

Construction, access to the body seat face, welding done

Top entry preferred; any new weld on the boundary re-opens qualification

Hand lapping that destroys the geometry the seat ring locates on

Test scope

100 cycle log, thermal cycles, repeat seat test

Torque curve delivered, second seat test after cycling

Assembly errors that only appear on the second operation

7. Cores, attrition and the arithmetic nobody does

An exchange programme is a stock problem before it is an engineering problem. Between 30 and 40 percent of valves returned for rebuild are condemned, which means a programme that needs a hundred serviceable valves has to source about a hundred and forty cores. The core charge, the inspection labour on the condemned units, and the scrap value are all real costs that do not appear on the rebuild quotation.

Freight is the second hidden line. A DN300 Class 600 trunnion valve weighs in the region of six hundred kilograms, so a container of forty valves is a heavy lift in both directions, and the round trip adds ten to fourteen weeks to a six to ten week rebuild. On a valve whose new lead time is sixteen to twenty-four weeks, that is still an advantage, but on a fast moving spare it is not.

The third line is the one that decides the business case, and it is almost never calculated. A rebuild costs 45 percent of the new price and delivers roughly half the service life, because the body has already consumed half its corrosion allowance and the trim is at its second or third generation. Cost per year of service is therefore about 90 percent of a new valve, before freight and before the working capital tied up in cores. Where a rebuild is genuinely cheaper is where the body is sound, the trim is being fully replaced, and the alternative is a twenty week wait on a line that is down. Where it is not cheaper is where the body is marginal and the valve is going back into the duty that killed it, which is the single most common outcome in a poorly run programme: a valve that failed in slurry service in four months is rebuilt and returned to the same line, and fails again in five.

8. Residue, origin and the paperwork that travels with a used valve

A used valve is not an empty object. It contains residues of whatever it last carried, in the cavity, in the seat pockets and in the packing, and that residue determines how it may be shipped. A cleaning certificate and a statement that the valve is not restricted for transport are baseline documents for any cross border movement, and they are the shipper's responsibility rather than the workshop's.

Two categories need more than a cleaning certificate. Valves from oil and gas production can carry naturally occurring radioactive material in the scale inside the body, and a valve with a NORM reading above the exemption level is a different shipment with different paperwork. Valves from sour or amine service carry a residual hazard that a water wash does not remove, and the declaration has to name the last process fluid rather than describing it as hydrocarbon service. Neither of these is exotic; both are routine in a mature rebuild programme, and both are routinely omitted from the enquiry.

9. What to write in the rebuild purchase order

Seven clauses convert the whole discussion into something a workshop can be held to. First, the route: repair, refurbish or remanufacture, named explicitly, with the replacement parts listed against it. Second, the wall thickness acceptance criterion expressed against the B16.34 table minimum for the size and class, with a measurement grid defined and a map delivered. Third, the certificate type that will be issued, agreed before the work starts, and a statement of what happens if the heat number turns out to be illegible. Fourth, the ball acceptance: minimum coating thickness after grinding, roundness, and a requirement that a ground ball is matched with a new seat. Fifth, the test schedule including the hundred cycle test, the thermal cycles where applicable, and the repeat seat test afterwards, with data delivered rather than summarised. Sixth, the residue declaration and cleaning certificate as a condition of shipment. Seventh, the warranty, stated as a period from installation rather than from delivery, with the freight liability on a failed unit named.

None of that is unreasonable, and a workshop that does this work properly will recognise every line of it. The quotation that comes back with an objection to the wall thickness grid is telling you which of the four routes it intends to take regardless of what the order says.

10. Buying the valve that does not need rebuilding

J-VALVES supplies new ball valves in bores from DN15 through DN1400, a half inch to 56 inch, in ASME 150 up to 2500, and can hold the face to face dimension of the valve you are thinking of rebuilding so that the pipe does not have to move. Every valve ships with the heat number on the body and repeated on the certificate, the trim code as a discrete line, and seat and seal kits listed against that code, which are the three items that make a rebuild possible fifteen years later. Shell proof at one hundred and fifty percent and seat proof at one hundred and ten percent are reported with the test direction. If a rebuild is the better answer for your population, we will say so; if it is not, the comparison, priced line by line, leaves the desk within three working hours.

11. Frequently Asked Questions

How much cheaper should a remanufactured ball valve be?

Around 45 to 60 percent of the new price for a genuine remanufacture with a new ball, new seats and a re-certified body, and 25 to 40 percent for a refurbishment that reuses the trim. Below about 40 percent for a claimed remanufacture, the ball has almost certainly been ground rather than replaced, and the sealing margin has already been spent. The number to compare is not the price but the price divided by the expected service life, which for a rebuild is typically half that of a new valve.

Can a rebuilt valve still carry an EN 10204 3.1 certificate?

Only if the original heat number is still legible on the body and no welding has been carried out on the pressure boundary during the rebuild. The 3.1 is a traceability statement about a specific heat, and it cannot be recreated by testing a finished valve. Without the heat number the honest document is a 2.2, which states that the supplier tested and considers the result to conform. That is a legitimate document, but it does not satisfy a specification that calls for 3.1.

Why can a rebuilt valve not be certified for low temperature service?

Because the qualification rests on Charpy impact values, and impact testing destroys the test pieces. A used body has no test pieces to cut, and subsize specimens from a thin wall need a correlation to full size values that the original certificate does not provide. If the original 3.1 with impact data survives and no welding was done, the material qualification carries over. If it does not, the valve can be tested hydrostatically all day and still have no evidence about brittle fracture.

Is a rebuilt valve acceptable in an emergency shutdown function?

Only with the same functional evidence a new valve would need, which in practice means a documented cycle test, a torque log, and a proven closure time under the actual differential. A rebuilt valve also cannot inherit a fire certificate, because a fire test qualifies a specific design and a specific test article, not a family of valves that have been through a workshop. For safety instrumented functions most operators require a new valve, and the rebuild premium saved is small compared with the proof test interval it costs.

What wall thickness should be accepted on a used valve body?

The value in the ASME B16.34 minimum wall table for that size and class, with no tolerance applied. For DN100 this is about 9.5 millimetres in Class 150, 12.7 in Class 300 and 17.5 in Class 600. The twelve and a half percent mill tolerance that is routinely applied to pipe and plate does not apply here, because the table values are already minimums. Readings should come from a defined grid and be delivered as a map, since a single minimum figure is invariably taken at the most accessible point.

Related Products

Explore the Valves in This Article
Nominal Size: 1 inch / DN25, range 1/4 to 12 inch Pressure Class: ASME Class 150, 19.6 bar at 38°C; Class 300 optional Body Material: ASTM B148 C95800 nickel aluminum bronze Body Type: Two piece, bolted Ball: C95800, SS316 hard faced optional Stem: C95800 or SS316, blowout proof Seat: PTFE, RPTFE, PPL, or reinforced PTFE Packing: PTFE or graphite combined packing End Connection: Threaded NPT / BSPT, flanged RF to ASME B16.5 optional Service Temperature: -29°C to +150°C standard, +200°C high temperature version Seawater Velocity Limit: About 6 m/s clean, 4.5 m/s with sand Design Standard: API 608, ASME B16.34 Test Standard: API 598, ISO 5208 Operation: Lever standard, pneumatic or electric optional
Size Range: 2 to 56 inch (DN50 to DN1400) Pressure Class: ASME Class 150 to 2500 / PN20 to PN420 Body Material: WCB, LCB, CF8, CF8M, CF3M, duplex, alloy steel Ball: Stainless with hard chrome, ENP, Stellite or tungsten carbide overlay Seat: PTFE, RPTFE, PPL, or metal Stellite faced Seat Arrangement: SPE, DPE (DIB-1), or combination (DIB-2) Packing: Live loaded graphite, ISO 15848-1 qualified Fire Test: API 607, also API 6FA and ISO 10497 Fugitive Emission: ISO 15848-1 class B or A, with temperature and cycle class stated Face to Face: ASME B16.10 short or long pattern End Connection: Flanged RF / RTJ to B16.5 and B16.47, butt weld to B16.25 Features: Double block and bleed, sealant injection, anti-static, anti-blowout stem Design Standard: API 6D, API 608, ASME B16.34, ISO 14313 Operation: Lever, gear, pneumatic, electric, hydraulic, gas over oil Sour Service: NACE MR0175 available
Nominal Size: 1-1/2 inch / DN40 Pressure Rating: 1000 WOG (68.9 bar cold working, non-shock) Body Type: Three piece, bolted end caps, four body bolts Body Material: ASTM A351 CF8 (304), CF8M (316) optional Ball: CF8, polished Ra 0.4 µm, full or reduced bore Seat: PTFE, RPTFE, PPL, or Stellite faced metal Body Gasket: PTFE to 180°C, graphite above Packing: PTFE V-ring to 200°C, graphite above End Connection: NPT, BSP, socket weld B16.11, butt weld B16.25, flanged RF Actuator Mounting: ISO 5211 F05 / F07 pad Air Supply: 0.4 to 0.7 MPa clean dry air Service Temperature: -29°C to +260°C, seat dependent Design Reference: MSS SP-110 general purpose, ASME B16.34 body wall Test Standard: API 598, ISO 5208
Nominal Size: 3/4 x 1/2 inch (DN20 x DN15), reduced bore Pressure Class: ASME Class 600 / PN100, 102.1 bar at 38°C Body Material: ASTM A182 F51 forged duplex, UNS S31803 PREN: Approximately 35 Ball: F51 with HVOF tungsten carbide or Stellite overlay Stem: F51, SS316 or 17-4PH, blowout proof Seat: RPTFE, Devlon, PEEK, or Stellite faced metal Bolting: B8M Class 2, alloy 718, or B7M for sour service End Connection: NPT, BSP, socket weld ASME B16.11, butt weld ASME B16.25 Bleed Port: Cavity bleed with plug or needle valve, lockable option Service Temperature: -29°C to +300°C, seat dependent Design Standard: API 6D, API 608, ASME B16.34 Test Standard: API 598, ISO 5208, cavity test through bleed port Sour Service: NACE MR0175 available